I think most females can say they have watched at least part of an episode of TLC’s Toddlers and Tiaras for no other reason than plain curiosity. People wonder what on Earth these parents are going to make their children do next, how much money they are willing to spend on ridiculous outfits and fake hair and who knows what else. It’s something that most consider unnatural and therefore sparks interest in a viewing audience.
I don’t watch the show religiously by any means but I do catch episodes from time to time whether by myself or with my roommate, boyfriend or mom. Sometimes, when I’m at work, coworkers will also bring up the show in conversation and I’ve even had people compare me either to the little girls or the pageant moms themselves simply because I’m a dance teacher.
After this had happened a few times it made me start watching the show with a different purpose. I was no longer just interested in the outfits or what kind of routines the moms with little to no dance background were going to come up with. Instead, I was consciously looking for comparisons between beauty pageants and dance recitals/competitions.
Today, I have come to this conclusion. While there may be some similarities between the two, they are not able to be equally compared because while a dance competition is based on skill, a beauty competition is based strictly on appearance. Let me be more specific.
While watching an episode of Toddlers and Tiaras this afternoon a little girl, Rylan, who had placed 3rd runner up in her age division asked her mom why Emily, who had been crowned queen, do so much better than she did. The mom responded, “She just had a better day than you did,” which I thought I was a rather appropriate answer. Then the dad said, “You just need to practice more.” That’s when the light bulb went off in my head.
Growing up as a dancer, I went to class multiple times a week and built a foundation of consistent skills to then go out on stage and present to a panel of judges. Although at the time of competition I would put on a costume and wear my hair a certain way and put on stage make-up, I was being judged 95% overall on my ability to dance.
When I watch these pageants, these little girls are being judged on something that they technically aren’t supposed to have to practice. Sure they go home and “practice” their routines or their special walk or their smiles but those are things that a child should do naturally. Not only that, but pageants judge these children on their fake hair, extremely expensive outfits, fake teeth and quite frankly, fake smiles. A child who goes on stage and only copies with their mom is doing out in the audience isn’t genuine. It’s not a skill. There you go, beauty is not a skill. And at the age of five or six, who is supposed to tell one child that they are more beautiful than another?
What Rylan’s dad should have said was, “Well honey, Emily is just more beautiful than you are. That’s why she did better than you today.”
So here is my conclusion and my response to anyone who compares dance competitions and recitals to beauty pageants; dance is something you can practice and get better at., beauty is not.